Giants Rumors: Kadarius Toney Trade Eyed by Teams; Execs Think NY May Make Move at WR
October 18, 2022
Giants Rumors: Kadarius Toney Trade Eyed by Teams; Execs Think NY May Make Move at WR
45 comments
Who is this Kadarius Toney you speak of? Is it some mythological creature?
I wonder what we can even get for him. Is a 2nd even possible?
Either way Toney bums me out. Guy has so much potential.
The only way they can trade him now is if he wasn’t really that injured to begin with. You cant trade injured players unless your giving teams a pick to take them for cap reasons only (Aqib Talib).
Unless Toney actually gets on the field and does something he is not going to have any trade value, even if Giants really REALLY want to trade him away.
I’ve liked Toney and genuinely wanted him to work out here but at this point it’s looking less and less likely with each game. Probably best for both parties for some sort of trade to happen though I’m not super optimistic about what we’d get for him.
I genuinely don’t understand this guy. And what on earth could we actually get for him? Either he’s genuinely injured so much he’s only able to appear in like 8 games in 2 years or he’s just refusing to take the field for the team that drafted him and is currently winning. What the fuck?
I could see him succeeding in an offense like Arizona where Murray is always scrambling and looking for receivers to scramble with him.
How about we just let the guy get healthy?
Despite all the frustration with injuries I don’t think I’m a fan of trading him. He’s a guy with WR1 potential who’s barely making $4 million a year and this would be selling him at rock bottom. I couldn’t see us getting higher than a 5th rounder in return.
Any chance teams are also eyeing Golladay and his contract??
He’s all yours Green Bay.
We could toss him in as compensation for taking on a gigantic salary. Someone whose year is shot might consider taking Galloday and Toney together and then dumping Galloday.
Too bad Urban Meyer is out of the league
Kadarius Toney doesn’t exist, it’s the parents
It obviously depends on how Thib’s career pans out (and this is only a point with the power of hindsight) but man, this idiot has really taken a lot of the glow off the 2021 draft trade since we could have just taken Parsons…though you can of course make the argument that maybe Parsons adds extra wins last year and we don’t get Neal this year. Still. Even if we made the trade it’s looking like taking basically anyone else at that spot would have been the move.
If we trade Toney for the incredibly low return we would get for him at this point, it almost guarantees that he will get healthy and start balling for whomever picks em up
In basically 1 game, Wandale Robinson proved he can a) ball, b) help the team win games, c) cares about giants football, d) can find success in the NFL without a rap career.
Getting anything for him at this point is a win
Can we just get rid of Galloday?
Who is going to want him. Dude is made of glass
This is fake news! Never heard of this ghost wr! 😂
He’s the kind of player you get when you don’t have any glaring holes (like we did on the OL, for example), not an everyday player. Somebody else can make better use of his skills when he’s healthy, but right now, we have an issue at WR. It could be mutually beneficial.
I don’t understand what team would take him… it would have to be a bottom of the barrel team trying to get a first round WR and hoping he will get healthy for the future. And whatever his value is, isn’t worth it… I’m sure it’s like a 4th round pick. I’d rather stick with him..
No contender would try and trade for someone who can’t get on the field
can you package golladay with him
Any teams have too much cap space? We have a great offer for you!
Curious – Has anyone ever seen Kadarius Toney and Jed Lowrie in the same room together?
Doesn’t make any sense to trade him
Keep him and let him get healthy. Why trade an asset for pennies on the dollar? We won’t get equal value and it’ll just put an incentive on him to perform big for someone else. Eat his contract and develop him.
I don’t see us getting much for him and with our receiver corps we desperately need the talent. After watching all the dropped balls these past few seasons we need to have a guy with good hands, speed, and the shiftiness Toney has. If he can get through all of these injuries/issues, imagine being in the mix for a playoff berth late in the season and having this dude ball out.
Trade a first round pick for what? A 3rd or 4th rounder? That’s hustling backwards
I don‘t see it, you never sell low
They can only have him if they take Golladay and his contact as well
We should be grabbing WR not giving them away.
Trade this guy!! He does nothing, even if he comes back he will literally break himself within a week or two… David Stills is a god in terms of actual production next to this clown shoe wearing mother fucker.. i’d trade him for hot dog at this point..
I think if im the giants and a team looking to trade for him, i want to see him at least play a game..m
It’s more complicated than some people let on. You don’t want to dump him for nothing – you’d rather try to get something resembling a decent return, but his production and injury record to date doesn’t really give you a chance to get anything higher than a 4th round pick.
So you say hang on to the guy until he’s healthy – but if it’s more than that, if there are behind the scenes concerns with him too, you have a dilemma. Keep him around and if he’s disgruntled, it can impact others. It also shows a reluctance of the organization to set free a guy they know they don’t want, which is bad practice. One of the reasons players hated Gettleman as much as they did was his treatment of their peers; these guys talk, and don’t appreciate having one of their own shit on.
I think the Giants will try to do right by KT and send him off. They’ll get less in return than we’d like, but in the grand scheme of things will be better off for it.
Dont we need WRs direly?
Bleacher report…….next.
How can we trade a player that doesn’t exist?
what’s to stop this team from going all in ?
there really isn’t any team in the NFC that scares me.
the best team right now is the eagles and we all know there’s nothing special about them.
tampa bay is falling hard, green bay sucks, LA sucks. We seriously have a legit shot at a super bowl.
now, could we beat KC or Buffalo? Hell no. But just getting there would be insane.
If you’re selling now, you’re selling so low, so unless someone is willing to drastically overpay, I don’t get this.
He’s hurt all the time yes, but you don’t give up on talent. Barkley couldn’t stay healthy… suddenly he is, and he’s killing it.
No way you even get a 5th with him being Mr. Glass
Bye bye
Man this would be one of the worst draft pick turnarounds in my book. First round draft, plays 1 good game in 2 years, then right at the cusp of his healthiness trade him for like a 5th?
At this point just keep him and use him when he’s ready? There’s no chance we get back anything more valuable than a 4th.
Trade a 👻
Clickbait article, no one is going to trade for a player who has never performed on the field and can’t stay on it for large chunks of the season. Our best bet with Toney is hope that he eventually gets healthy enough to be a distraction in a couple of games late on in the season before he goes on IR.
45 comments
Who is this Kadarius Toney you speak of? Is it some mythological creature?
I wonder what we can even get for him. Is a 2nd even possible?
Either way Toney bums me out. Guy has so much potential.
The only way they can trade him now is if he wasn’t really that injured to begin with. You cant trade injured players unless your giving teams a pick to take them for cap reasons only (Aqib Talib).
Unless Toney actually gets on the field and does something he is not going to have any trade value, even if Giants really REALLY want to trade him away.
I’ve liked Toney and genuinely wanted him to work out here but at this point it’s looking less and less likely with each game. Probably best for both parties for some sort of trade to happen though I’m not super optimistic about what we’d get for him.
I genuinely don’t understand this guy. And what on earth could we actually get for him? Either he’s genuinely injured so much he’s only able to appear in like 8 games in 2 years or he’s just refusing to take the field for the team that drafted him and is currently winning. What the fuck?
I could see him succeeding in an offense like Arizona where Murray is always scrambling and looking for receivers to scramble with him.
How about we just let the guy get healthy?
Despite all the frustration with injuries I don’t think I’m a fan of trading him. He’s a guy with WR1 potential who’s barely making $4 million a year and this would be selling him at rock bottom. I couldn’t see us getting higher than a 5th rounder in return.
Any chance teams are also eyeing Golladay and his contract??
He’s all yours Green Bay.
We could toss him in as compensation for taking on a gigantic salary. Someone whose year is shot might consider taking Galloday and Toney together and then dumping Galloday.
Too bad Urban Meyer is out of the league
Kadarius Toney doesn’t exist, it’s the parents
It obviously depends on how Thib’s career pans out (and this is only a point with the power of hindsight) but man, this idiot has really taken a lot of the glow off the 2021 draft trade since we could have just taken Parsons…though you can of course make the argument that maybe Parsons adds extra wins last year and we don’t get Neal this year. Still. Even if we made the trade it’s looking like taking basically anyone else at that spot would have been the move.
If we trade Toney for the incredibly low return we would get for him at this point, it almost guarantees that he will get healthy and start balling for whomever picks em up
In basically 1 game, Wandale Robinson proved he can a) ball, b) help the team win games, c) cares about giants football, d) can find success in the NFL without a rap career.
Getting anything for him at this point is a win
Can we just get rid of Galloday?
Who is going to want him. Dude is made of glass
This is fake news! Never heard of this ghost wr! 😂
He’s the kind of player you get when you don’t have any glaring holes (like we did on the OL, for example), not an everyday player. Somebody else can make better use of his skills when he’s healthy, but right now, we have an issue at WR. It could be mutually beneficial.
I don’t understand what team would take him… it would have to be a bottom of the barrel team trying to get a first round WR and hoping he will get healthy for the future. And whatever his value is, isn’t worth it… I’m sure it’s like a 4th round pick. I’d rather stick with him..
No contender would try and trade for someone who can’t get on the field
can you package golladay with him
Any teams have too much cap space? We have a great offer for you!
Curious – Has anyone ever seen Kadarius Toney and Jed Lowrie in the same room together?
Doesn’t make any sense to trade him
Keep him and let him get healthy. Why trade an asset for pennies on the dollar? We won’t get equal value and it’ll just put an incentive on him to perform big for someone else. Eat his contract and develop him.
I don’t see us getting much for him and with our receiver corps we desperately need the talent. After watching all the dropped balls these past few seasons we need to have a guy with good hands, speed, and the shiftiness Toney has. If he can get through all of these injuries/issues, imagine being in the mix for a playoff berth late in the season and having this dude ball out.
Trade a first round pick for what? A 3rd or 4th rounder? That’s hustling backwards
I don‘t see it, you never sell low
They can only have him if they take Golladay and his contact as well
We should be grabbing WR not giving them away.
Trade this guy!! He does nothing, even if he comes back he will literally break himself within a week or two… David Stills is a god in terms of actual production next to this clown shoe wearing mother fucker.. i’d trade him for hot dog at this point..
I think if im the giants and a team looking to trade for him, i want to see him at least play a game..m
It’s more complicated than some people let on. You don’t want to dump him for nothing – you’d rather try to get something resembling a decent return, but his production and injury record to date doesn’t really give you a chance to get anything higher than a 4th round pick.
So you say hang on to the guy until he’s healthy – but if it’s more than that, if there are behind the scenes concerns with him too, you have a dilemma. Keep him around and if he’s disgruntled, it can impact others. It also shows a reluctance of the organization to set free a guy they know they don’t want, which is bad practice. One of the reasons players hated Gettleman as much as they did was his treatment of their peers; these guys talk, and don’t appreciate having one of their own shit on.
I think the Giants will try to do right by KT and send him off. They’ll get less in return than we’d like, but in the grand scheme of things will be better off for it.
Dont we need WRs direly?
Bleacher report…….next.
How can we trade a player that doesn’t exist?
what’s to stop this team from going all in ?
there really isn’t any team in the NFC that scares me.
the best team right now is the eagles and we all know there’s nothing special about them.
tampa bay is falling hard, green bay sucks, LA sucks. We seriously have a legit shot at a super bowl.
now, could we beat KC or Buffalo? Hell no. But just getting there would be insane.
If you’re selling now, you’re selling so low, so unless someone is willing to drastically overpay, I don’t get this.
He’s hurt all the time yes, but you don’t give up on talent. Barkley couldn’t stay healthy… suddenly he is, and he’s killing it.
No way you even get a 5th with him being Mr. Glass
Bye bye
Man this would be one of the worst draft pick turnarounds in my book. First round draft, plays 1 good game in 2 years, then right at the cusp of his healthiness trade him for like a 5th?
At this point just keep him and use him when he’s ready? There’s no chance we get back anything more valuable than a 4th.
Trade a 👻
Clickbait article, no one is going to trade for a player who has never performed on the field and can’t stay on it for large chunks of the season.
Our best bet with Toney is hope that he eventually gets healthy enough to be a distraction in a couple of games late on in the season before he goes on IR.