Thoughts on this signed Brodeur puck. Authentic or not?
October 14, 2023
It comes with a COA and is low priced though. It doesn’t seem to be signed by Brodeur. Anyone have a clue about his signature?
7 comments
That is not a vezina trophy.
I have a few autographs of his and to be honest this doesn’t look like his signature compared to what I have and what I’ve seen. That doesn’t mean it’s fake but I’d research the company that authorized it as legitimate and see what conclusion you can come to becuase on a quickgoogle search nothing on this company really came up. Also as another person pointed out this says it’s a vezina and it’s a puck which leads me to believe someone made this without doing their research so it has a few red flags for me
That is not Martin Brodeurs autograph.
Yeah. Look into who the company is that did the COA. It may be authentic… but his autograph usually has his number(not a dead give away this is fake he may not have done it for this) and it looks kind of off. I’m not an expert but it looks off from the one I’m currently looking at. There’s another I have that I got from an old coworker with the 12-13 team I’m pretty sure they had some intern from the team signing bc the signature isn’t even close.
The one is from the banner hanging night for Marty and isn’t a pen signature but basically a copy. The picture with him holding the cup is a live autograph with a COA.
his autograph usually looks like a MTBR with a 30 next to it, so that might be somebody’s signature but it doesn’t look like Marty’s at all.
Ive had marty sign multiple things before, using his free and paid for autograph, and this looks like neither of them.
I am no autograph expert but I am familiar with his signature and this isn’t it.
Edit. Just looked at the certificate and that is super shady itself. “The item accompanied by this certificate” ? That sounds very vague. Could anyone sign anything and just put this thing next to it and make it an authentic signature?
7 comments
That is not a vezina trophy.
I have a few autographs of his and to be honest this doesn’t look like his signature compared to what I have and what I’ve seen. That doesn’t mean it’s fake but I’d research the company that authorized it as legitimate and see what conclusion you can come to becuase on a quickgoogle search nothing on this company really came up. Also as another person pointed out this says it’s a vezina and it’s a puck which leads me to believe someone made this without doing their research so it has a few red flags for me
That is not Martin Brodeurs autograph.
Yeah. Look into who the company is that did the COA. It may be authentic… but his autograph usually has his number(not a dead give away this is fake he may not have done it for this) and it looks kind of off. I’m not an expert but it looks off from the one I’m currently looking at. There’s another I have that I got from an old coworker with the 12-13 team I’m pretty sure they had some intern from the team signing bc the signature isn’t even close.
[for comparison sake](https://imgur.com/a/uqD0qPR)
The one is from the banner hanging night for Marty and isn’t a pen signature but basically a copy. The picture with him holding the cup is a live autograph with a COA.
his autograph usually looks like a MTBR with a 30 next to it, so that might be somebody’s signature but it doesn’t look like Marty’s at all.
Ive had marty sign multiple things before, using his free and paid for autograph, and this looks like neither of them.
I am no autograph expert but I am familiar with his signature and this isn’t it.
Edit. Just looked at the certificate and that is super shady itself. “The item accompanied by this certificate” ? That sounds very vague. Could anyone sign anything and just put this thing next to it and make it an authentic signature?