I want a QB but if this is what it comes down to on draft day…I want Malik Nabers

26 comments

1. This would definitely be a Giants trade up scenario.

2. If all QBs are off the board, Malik Nabers just has to be our guy. He’s easily WR1 in so many previous draft classes but unfortunately he’s sharing the spotlight with MHJ.

3. Did everyone forget about the combine? Did everyone forget that there’s other QBs? Did everyone forget that a bunch of QBs always shoot up on draft boards because they look great at the combine and that the teams above us would probably fall in love with them?

4. If this is the situation we’re in we must **MUST** trade back into this first round for a qb, we cannot enter the 2024 season with post ACL tear DJ being the only plan at QB. If that’s what they do, you can almost certainly write the 2020s off for the Giants.

5. I will fucking cry if Nabers has to go toil in vrables bullshit offense.

6. Glad we won all those meaningless games against terrible teams

7. no way not w olu on the board

8. Is Nabers that good because this feels like a brutal drop between picks 4 and 5

9. Mock Draft hopes and its not even January 😂

10. Maybe, Williams, mhj, nabers. Everyone jumping on the Jayden train needs to look at some of the last few QBs who rocketed up boards late due beneficial circumstances. The strategy of building a strong core and dropping a QB into the right situation has provided much stronger results and more recently. Sure one of the other non maye or Williams QBs might turn out alright but more likely they end up a bust. Biding time arch manning anyways

11. watch caleb williams pull an eli manning and refuse the call to carolina

    edit: the bears I MEAN THE BEARS

12. I think this is a two qb draft with Maye and Williams, but a lot of people want Jayden Daniels.

    Nabers is a special wide receiver. Fast, physical, solid route running, always high pointing the ball, and tracks the ball really well.

13. Fix the OL. Fix the DL. Then we can talk receivers.

14. In this position I feel like trading back for Nix or McCarthy is the move

15. If QB is gone then WR is the way to go. Elite WR are way more impactful than OL since you need more then one to be solid. Plenty of analytic work shows you just need average offensive lineman play to be good. Having one elite and 4 duds is still a problem. Receiver who can get open quickly or you just trust in toss ups can allow for quicker plays.

16. No way, Joe Alt all the way. Need linemen who can stay healthy

17. I am SO SICK of drafting OT in Top-5 and having them be busts. I’d rather draft Nabers or just trade back honestly.

18. Give me Nabers then a big dick move and trade back into the first for Penix. I just really like Penix honestly

19. The issue with Nabers is he’s yet another undersized WR to add to our already very undersized WR room.

    I really like Odunze. He’s the kind of contested catch and red zone threat that we’re missing.

    Separately, Washington getting duped into drafting another future bust UNC QB would be fucking hilarious

20. Imo one of the QBs will be available. Imo the Bears are trading down or taking MHJ. I think we will have great options at our current spot.

21. Definitely an unpopular opinion but if we can’t work out a trade for a QB, I’m trading down and taking an edge. We are one of the worst pass rushing teams in the league. Part of that is because of Wink’s scheme, but also outside of Dex and Kayvon we don’t really have anyone who can rush the passer. Nabers is an animal but it’s a very deep WR class. We can very easily get a WR1 at the top of the second or if we trade back into the bottom of the first. This edge class is very top heavy and I would love to pair Kayvon with Latu or Dallas Turner or Trice

22. I want us to trade up for a QB that the FO likes fk all that other shit. This season would be a complete waste if we end up w a top 5 pick and we pick another lineman . Ik our Oline is bad but I’d want to change coaches before spending another high pick on a lineman. We desperately need a QB and it’d 100% be worth the trade if the QB they like ends up being a star.

23. Maybe an unpopular opinion but I’d like to see a solid addition to the OL that is actually worth a damn to protect whatever QB is at the helm

24. Nabers would be fun but he won’t bring us wins. We’ll be OBJ giants all over again, which wasn’t the worst thing.

    We are struggling to even find an identity. We need to leverage Dexy and Kayvon and create an elite DLine, mix things up on OLine, and get back to grinding out Ws with Saquon.

25. It’s amateur scout season already?

26. But Joe Alt just sounds like a hall of fame name for an OL