MLB Active Home Run Leaders – who ends up with the most?
January 12, 2024
How does this list end?
41 comments
Arenado probably gets to number 1 is my guess
Harper or Arenado
Harper would be my bet
Bryce or Manny
Bryce
king harper
If Trout and Stanton didn’t get hurt all the time they’d be vying for 500.
What is Trout on pace to hit for his career? I figured he had more homers than that
I did not realize Manny had 313. It’s got to be him, Bryce or Nolan.
Harper or Manny.
Trout. I say this hoping he starts to DH more and stays healthy. He will get to 500 regardless
I think it ends up being Stanton, with Harper and Machado having the best shot to overtake. My thinking is Stanton has three years left before club option, so I doubt he’ll call it quits before then. Even though he s the stank last year, he still managed 20+ hr. I don’t think 45 more is out of the realm of possibility.
Trout or Arenado are my bets.
isn’t trout a year less active than stanton
Bryce
It’s Stanton, and I have no clue how anyone could pick anyone else. Trout is the only other player who will even make it to 400 (maybe Machado) but he’s hurt as much as Stanton is every year.
A bunch of superstars on the list no doubt — but all of them have longevity/health concerns in my book. I’m going to go with Harper.
I had no idea Longo was so high up there
Considering Giancarlo runs like me when I was 300 pounds as a tenth grader and gets hurt if you look at him funny, I say anyone but him
Stanton going to have the quietest 500 HR career ever. Mind boggling he’s already past 400.
Man o man o manny
Harper and Arenado. Arenado gets to 500 quietly like Beltre before him.
Either Harper or Trout
Trout or Harper!!
I think Nolan has a great shot to beat the rest of this list.
I wouldn’t look past Freddie this next few years. Batting behind Ohtani, speed on paths he will see a lot more fastballs.
Mike Trout
Machado.
Trout, Machado, or Bryce. All three of whom should end up being first ballot HOF.
If Stanton stays healthy, and that’s a big if, none of these guys are catching him
With the way the roster is constructed in LA, even with Freddie starting to head downhill in the next 1 to 2 years, I’d have to put my money on him batting between Mookie and Shohei, I’d be surprised if he doesn’t hit 45+ HRs/yr the next couple of years.
Bryce on top, Trout second, Manny third
Harper, and he could end up with 700
Trout passes Stanton in 2026.
Trout is gonna play seven more years and hit at least 20 a year which would put him over 500. It’s trout.
Sigh J.D. back too Lmaoo I’m surprised he’s still a free agent
Trout if he stays healthy. I think Bryce Harper will have the most.
Feels like half of Goldschmidt’s were against the Giants.
Elias Diaz 😭
Does anyone else think Stanton doesn’t belong in the HOF? Basically another Adam Dunn, plus injuries.
41 comments
Arenado probably gets to number 1 is my guess
Harper or Arenado
Harper would be my bet
Bryce or Manny
Bryce
king harper
If Trout and Stanton didn’t get hurt all the time they’d be vying for 500.
What is Trout on pace to hit for his career? I figured he had more homers than that
I did not realize Manny had 313. It’s got to be him, Bryce or Nolan.
Harper or Manny.
Trout. I say this hoping he starts to DH more and stays healthy. He will get to 500 regardless
I think it ends up being Stanton, with Harper and Machado having the best shot to overtake. My thinking is Stanton has three years left before club option, so I doubt he’ll call it quits before then. Even though he s the stank last year, he still managed 20+ hr. I don’t think 45 more is out of the realm of possibility.
Trout or Arenado are my bets.
isn’t trout a year less active than stanton
Bryce
It’s Stanton, and I have no clue how anyone could pick anyone else. Trout is the only other player who will even make it to 400 (maybe Machado) but he’s hurt as much as Stanton is every year.
A bunch of superstars on the list no doubt — but all of them have longevity/health concerns in my book. I’m going to go with Harper.
I had no idea Longo was so high up there
Considering Giancarlo runs like me when I was 300 pounds as a tenth grader and gets hurt if you look at him funny, I say anyone but him
Stanton going to have the quietest 500 HR career ever. Mind boggling he’s already past 400.
Man o man o manny
Harper and Arenado. Arenado gets to 500 quietly like Beltre before him.
Either Harper or Trout
Trout or Harper!!
I think Nolan has a great shot to beat the rest of this list.
I wouldn’t look past Freddie this next few years. Batting behind Ohtani, speed on paths he will see a lot more fastballs.
Mike Trout
Machado.
Trout, Machado, or Bryce. All three of whom should end up being first ballot HOF.
If Stanton stays healthy, and that’s a big if, none of these guys are catching him
With the way the roster is constructed in LA, even with Freddie starting to head downhill in the next 1 to 2 years, I’d have to put my money on him batting between Mookie and Shohei, I’d be surprised if he doesn’t hit 45+ HRs/yr the next couple of years.
Bryce on top, Trout second, Manny third
Harper, and he could end up with 700
Trout passes Stanton in 2026.
Trout is gonna play seven more years and hit at least 20 a year which would put him over 500. It’s trout.
Sigh J.D. back too Lmaoo I’m surprised he’s still a free agent
Trout if he stays healthy. I think Bryce Harper will have the most.
Feels like half of Goldschmidt’s were against the Giants.
Elias Diaz 😭
Does anyone else think Stanton doesn’t belong in the HOF? Basically another Adam Dunn, plus injuries.
Does Mike Stanton get to 500?