My legitimate only hesitation with Harper at 3 is how truly awful his defense was there last year. His bat is amazing, but many times he looked unplayable.
It feels hard for me putting him above Alonso even with his insane bat because of that.
That said, even serviceable defense in 2024 and he’s easily 3, or arguably even 2
Olson had an outlier year, and while I definitely still agree he is top 3, on don’t think the outlier can be ignored until he repeats it.
fuck matt olson
All worked out better than even could have hoped for both the Braves and Dodgers.
6 comments
Fair
Seems about right. No argument here
My legitimate only hesitation with Harper at 3 is how truly awful his defense was there last year. His bat is amazing, but many times he looked unplayable.
It feels hard for me putting him above Alonso even with his insane bat because of that.
That said, even serviceable defense in 2024 and he’s easily 3, or arguably even 2
Olson had an outlier year, and while I definitely still agree he is top 3, on don’t think the outlier can be ignored until he repeats it.
fuck matt olson
All worked out better than even could have hoped for both the Braves and Dodgers.
It’s not wrong… yet!