Quarterback efficiency…anything stick out?

38 comments

1. r/TopRightMahomes

2. Clearly the two best QBs in football played on Sunday

3. Geno is good at completing passes

4. Hurts is a lot better than people give him credit for.

5. Actually my favorite is since 2012 the closest player to Brady is Jimmy G

6. 16-84 win probability seems strangely specific. Any reason for that?

7. I think the difference between Watson on the first graph and the 2nd one is nuts. He went from being next to hall of fame level QBs to being next to Zach Wilson and Bryce Young lol

8. Mahhomes is clearly regressing to the mean.

9. What does “above expected” refer to?

10. Zach Wilson is either really good or really bad.

    I can’t read charts.

11. I see one game manager looking pretty good, and Purdy isn’t bad either.

12. Trevor Lawrence is overrated?

13. The Browns could have had Zach Wilson for basically free and got roughly the same performance.

14. Oof Zach Wilson…Jets bros I’m sorry

15. I *really dislike* how close Luck and Lock are in the second graph

16. We get it Patrick, you’re good. Stop being a dick.

17. How much hate Hurts and Purdy get when they’re both balling.

18. Holy crap didn’t realize Watson was that bad

19. The Andy Dalton metric was always spot on.

20. Dolphin reddit wants to get rid of Tua for Baker….hell to the no!

21. A 16% garbage time filter is insanely aggressive. You’re just straight cutting out like 30% of QBs snaps there. Like Josh Allen legit has 600+ snaps removed in the 2021-2023 chart with that filter.

    You can be down 0-3 in the first quarter and have a win probability under 16% or up 3-0 in the first quarter and have a win probability over 84%.

    Doesn’t make sense IMO.

22. Jalen my dawg 😤😤

23. Geno Smith.

24. Yes – we would have been slaughtered if Purdy had even a half second longer to throw per play.

25. Romo and Dak are light-years better than what most people give them credit for…

26. Andy Dalton right in the middle

27. Man Zach Wilson sucks

28. Patrick Mahomes is really, really good and Zach Wilson is really, really bad.

29. CJ stroud is better than Tom Brady

30. Mahomes is combining the power of both Brock Purdy and Geno Smith into one super quarterback?

31. Fields is way higher on this graph than you would assume based on what this subreddit seems to think about him

32. Kirk is my King. screw you all dorks i’m drunk and commenting

33. Brock Purdy contract is a hell of a deal

34. CJ Stroud had an absolute knockout rookie season. If he continues to play like he did this year, there’s no telling where that Houston team could go.

35. >anything stick out?

    Yeah, for the love of god somebody save Bryce Young

36. Turns out Patrick Mahomes is a good quarterback, never would have guessed tbh

37. The story behind Purdy’s upcoming is honestly really amazing and I hope he keeps his momentum going. It’s eerily similar to how Tom Brady got his start. 

38. Philip Rivers is one of the greatest qbs to ever live and he will never get his flowers apparently