Start one, bench one, cut one. Recency bias is in full effect here. Have fun!
38 comments
I mean I love Jordan but I think the answer is pretty obvious here.
I START JORDAN AND CUT THE OTHER TWO BABY. THE FUTURE IS NOW, OLD MEN.
Start Love, bench Rodgers cause he’s injured and cut Favre cause he’s old as fuck and washed
Okay, so I’m going to assume prime Rodgers and Favre: Start Rodgers, Love on the bench just in case, and cut the QB I grew up with as a kid… Sorry Brett, there’s a much better chance 10VE comes off the bench and leads a final drive that doesn’t end in an INT.
Shut up, I know how the season ended. Don’t remind me.
We talking about primes? Start Rogers, cut Favre and bench love. I think judging by the end of the season, loves floor might end up being an interception prone gunslinger like Favre but his ceiling might be right up there with Rogers.
I haven’t watched Favre play, but I really thought people old say star Rodgers, bench Favre and cut Love.
It’s interesting to see people are hopeful for Love to be at least better than Brett
At their peak? Start Rodgers, bench Favre, cut Love.
Love me some J Love, but Start: Rodgers Bench: Brett Cut: Jordan
All in prime: start Rodgers bench Favre cut Love.
Everyone saying Favre sometimes had stinkers is right, but Favre also could will you to wins. In a backup qb is in situation, I’ll take it!
Alternative take, lowest points in career. Bench Rodgers, he’s flying on Ayahuasca ATM but he’s immunized. Cut Favre, the Weiner photo was enough. Start Love, he’s done nothing wrong and he’s learned from amazing athletes, and morally/ethically gray individuals.
Start: Love
Set Out To Ocean on a Raft: Rodgers
Arrested: Favre
Are we serious? Do people forget Favre was a 3x MVP? Rodgers 4x?
Start Love, Cut both Favre and Rodgers.
Start Rodgers, Bench Favre, Cut Love. Any other answer is just nonsense.
Start rodgers Bench Favre Cut Love
Anyone saying cut Favre not in jest is a fucking moron lol
Start Love. No cap
it’s too early to say with Love yet, but he’s on a really good path. as of rn i am starting Rodgers, benching Favre, and moving Love to the practice squad.
Some of you are really saying cut Farve?! I love Jordan, but come on.
If we are talking im their primes.
Start Rodgers, Bench Favre, and trade Love (the first two are 4x and 3x MVPs and Superbowl winners and while Jordan has shown a lot of promise he is not playing at 96-99 Favre level or 2010-2014 Rodgers level….yet)
If we are talking at their current age, today:
Start Love, try to get get Rodgers into some therapy and one of those conversatorships they had Brittany Spears under, and arrest and indite Favre.
We talking playoffs? If we are in playoffs Start Starr, bench Rodgers cut farve and love
You fucker
It’s gotta be start Rodgers, bench Favre and cut Love, but ask me again next year
They’re all in their prime right? As a ’90s kid Brett Favre was my guy but I’m starting prime Rodgers. Prime Rogers was super efficient and I think what a lot of people seem to forget is he also used to get a lot of yards with his legs. Love isn’t in his prime yet but he is very good and I really like how he matured and got better throughout this last season. I’m still going with 12
Edit: I didn’t fully answer the question start 12, bench 4, trade 10
Not playing this game
Start 12. Bench 4. Cut 10.
This question is 12 years or more too early. Come on now
In their primes, start favre, bench rodgers, cut love. Rodgers is an all time great but if im down 14 with 3 minutes left to play favre is the only one trying to win. If its the 4th and youre down 14 rodgers isnt getting it done
Start Farve, Bench Rodgers, Cut Love.
Now, I feel this debate really depends on what year you throw them all into and how for how many years. My biggest reason for saying Farve as my starter is because of the beatings he would take week in and week out. Also, a young in prime Farve had one of the greatest arms of the time, that even tho it looks normal now, could play in our league today and do very well in it.
Same thing for Rodgers, just more about when we are playing, and for how long and with what weapons, as I do feel like Rodgers could elevate weaker weapons to better statuses than Farve.
Love is just way to young and I don’t think anyone can tell how good he can be. If in 5 years he looks, sounds, and plays like he did from the “thankingiving feast” game vs Detroit to the loving “welcome home daddy” game against Dallas, then we this question becomes a little harder to answer.
What offense we running west coast rodgers favre all day. Lafleur version of Shanahan I am taking love bench rodgers
It’s between Favre and Rodgers, Rodgers was better in about everything other than deep throws. Favre also was tough as shit
Favre would have won the nfc divisional game in Green Bay in 2022
38 comments
I mean I love Jordan but I think the answer is pretty obvious here.
I START JORDAN AND CUT THE OTHER TWO BABY. THE FUTURE IS NOW, OLD MEN.
Start Love, bench Rodgers cause he’s injured and cut Favre cause he’s old as fuck and washed
Okay, so I’m going to assume prime Rodgers and Favre: Start Rodgers, Love on the bench just in case, and cut the QB I grew up with as a kid… Sorry Brett, there’s a much better chance 10VE comes off the bench and leads a final drive that doesn’t end in an INT.
Shut up, I know how the season ended. Don’t remind me.
We talking about primes? Start Rogers, cut Favre and bench love. I think judging by the end of the season, loves floor might end up being an interception prone gunslinger like Favre but his ceiling might be right up there with Rogers.
I haven’t watched Favre play, but I really thought people old say star Rodgers, bench Favre and cut Love.
It’s interesting to see people are hopeful for Love to be at least better than Brett
At their peak? Start Rodgers, bench Favre, cut Love.
Love me some J Love, but Start: Rodgers Bench: Brett Cut: Jordan
All in prime: start Rodgers bench Favre cut Love.
Everyone saying Favre sometimes had stinkers is right, but Favre also could will you to wins. In a backup qb is in situation, I’ll take it!
Alternative take, lowest points in career. Bench Rodgers, he’s flying on Ayahuasca ATM but he’s immunized. Cut Favre, the Weiner photo was enough. Start Love, he’s done nothing wrong and he’s learned from amazing athletes, and morally/ethically gray individuals.
Start: Love
Set Out To Ocean on a Raft: Rodgers
Arrested: Favre
Are we serious? Do people forget Favre was a 3x MVP? Rodgers 4x?
Start Love, Cut both Favre and Rodgers.
Start Rodgers, Bench Favre, Cut Love. Any other answer is just nonsense.
Start rodgers
Bench Favre
Cut Love
Anyone saying cut Favre not in jest is a fucking moron lol
Start Love. No cap
it’s too early to say with Love yet, but he’s on a really good path. as of rn i am starting Rodgers, benching Favre, and moving Love to the practice squad.
Some of you are really saying cut Farve?! I love Jordan, but come on.
If we are talking im their primes.
Start Rodgers, Bench Favre, and trade Love (the first two are 4x and 3x MVPs and Superbowl winners and while Jordan has shown a lot of promise he is not playing at 96-99 Favre level or 2010-2014 Rodgers level….yet)
If we are talking at their current age, today:
Start Love, try to get get Rodgers into some therapy and one of those conversatorships they had Brittany Spears under, and arrest and indite Favre.
We talking playoffs?
If we are in playoffs
Start Starr, bench Rodgers cut farve and love
You fucker
It’s gotta be start Rodgers, bench Favre and cut Love, but ask me again next year
They’re all in their prime right? As a ’90s kid Brett Favre was my guy but I’m starting prime Rodgers. Prime Rogers was super efficient and I think what a lot of people seem to forget is he also used to get a lot of yards with his legs. Love isn’t in his prime yet but he is very good and I really like how he matured and got better throughout this last season. I’m still going with 12
Edit: I didn’t fully answer the question start 12, bench 4, trade 10
Not playing this game
Start 12. Bench 4. Cut 10.
This question is 12 years or more too early. Come on now
In their primes, start favre, bench rodgers, cut love. Rodgers is an all time great but if im down 14 with 3 minutes left to play favre is the only one trying to win. If its the 4th and youre down 14 rodgers isnt getting it done
Start Farve, Bench Rodgers, Cut Love.
Now, I feel this debate really depends on what year you throw them all into and how for how many years. My biggest reason for saying Farve as my starter is because of the beatings he would take week in and week out. Also, a young in prime Farve had one of the greatest arms of the time, that even tho it looks normal now, could play in our league today and do very well in it.
Same thing for Rodgers, just more about when we are playing, and for how long and with what weapons, as I do feel like Rodgers could elevate weaker weapons to better statuses than Farve.
Love is just way to young and I don’t think anyone can tell how good he can be. If in 5 years he looks, sounds, and plays like he did from the “thankingiving feast” game vs Detroit to the loving “welcome home daddy” game against Dallas, then we this question becomes a little harder to answer.
What offense we running west coast rodgers favre all day. Lafleur version of Shanahan I am taking love bench rodgers
It’s between Favre and Rodgers, Rodgers was better in about everything other than deep throws. Favre also was tough as shit
Favre would have won the nfc divisional game in Green Bay in 2022
Start Love, Start Rodgers, Start Favre, Cut Brett Hundley
Start Love, bench Rodgers, cut Favre
Tempted to start Favre but he is 54!
Run 3 QB Packages.
Brett Favre is 54 years old. No way I’m starting that boomer
Going into 2nd season starting. Start Love, Favre backup cut Rodgers
Start Farve he won a ring, bench Aaron as he won a ring after sitting on the bench behind Farve, cut Love
I’d cut 12 before he asked to go to the Jets….
Start Love, bench Farve, cut Rodgers.
Rodgers off field stuff was too much. oOoOoOo HeAlINg CrYsTaLs AnD AyAhUaScA.
Start Love, doesn’t matter about the other two.
Start Favre , bench love, cut Rodgers.