This was posted as a serious question……


Have people already forgotten just how insanely good Mario was much less the other three?

25 comments
  1. Lots of respect for the Sedins game here. That being said, Jagr and Lemieux would run through the Sedins like they weren’t even there.

    It’s such a mismatch that Paul Coffey is not even a factor.

  2. I don’t even think the Sedins would pick their own team if they were asked to choose

  3. Edler was a good player, but not on the same level as Coffey. The Sedin twins were really good and had some insane chemistry on the ice, but better than Jagr and Lemieux? Please.

  4. Two of the most prolific scorers the game has ever seen, including one consistently regarded as the 2nd best ever(best in my book) and another who is 2nd all time in points scored. Twins are cool and all, but they’re outsized and skilled. Before anyone argues Mario never played defense or would be too slow for open ice, so dumb because he was an incredible skater, his 49 short handed goals alone are over eight times that of the entire Vancouver group. That matchup is a joke.

    One of the best skating defensemen who also happens to be second all time in points for defensemen. Edler vs Coffey, ok that’s a fucking joke.

    Two-time Stanley Cup winning goalkeeper against a guy who frankly, and this is harsh, but NEVER GOT IT DONE.

    I mean this as no disrespect to the Sedin twins, Edler, or Luongo, but if we’re going with in their primes then this is a slaughter.

  5. This is as pathetic as when Laviolette said Claude Giroux was better than Sid.

  6. I come in peace as a Canucks fan who had this pop up on their feed… that’s an insane question. No matter how good the Sedins may have been.

  7. Is this a sudden death, first goal wins overtime or a full on 3 vs. 3 game? Not that it changes the outcome. I’m just curious what kind of massacre we’re talking about here

  8. How on earth is this a serious question? Look, the Sedins are great but they aren’t shit to Mario and Jags.

  9. As a Canuck fan, I loved the Sedins and that 2011 team with Luongo and Edler almost go it done. But I am taking Lemieux, Jagr and Coffey every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

  10. Random shit that amuses me: Lemiueux/Jagr have a 90 lb advantage over the Sedins

    Barasso was also a very large man

  11. Yeah, no disrespect to Coffey but it doesn’t matter who the third player is for the Penguins, Lemieux and Jagr win every time.

Leave a Reply