Yeah I agree!! Let’s add another LT to the team although we already have an All Pro LT, to solidify the line
Edited: LT not RT
Moving Alt to Right tackle would be a waste, and he’s also never played there, he’s been a Left tackle his whole career, so it could be risky taking him and making him play Right tackle. We also just signed Eluemunor and id also like to Give Neal another year and see what he can do working with Bricillo, a very good O-Line coach.
Nah
Yeah this is a horrible idea, so as a Giants fan I believe it may happen.
My draft hot take is that Fashanu is going to be a better OT than Alt
We need a WR or QB, we have a LT already. We signed 2 linemen in the off season with one of them being a tackle and we got a new oline coach, we can’t keep going for oline this early when we have other needs
Nothing is guaranteed.
Can’t wait for the dogshit draft takes to stop for a few months
Just let Neal develop with a new coach before we throw in the towel. Guy has only played like 20 games
How do I delete this post
Na, we need to show we can develop what we have otherwise it’s Neal 2.0. We can’t draft our way to a better line, time to coach the guys up like the good orgs do.
While I disagree with this post, I also hate that people keep saying that it would be a waste to switch Alt to RT.
Most everyone here should be able to agree that we would love to have the Lion’s OL. Well, the Lion’s built that OL by going and drafting Penei Sewell 7th overall despite having a franchise LT in Taylor Decker — and in spite of Sewell never playing RT in college, is now an all pro RT.
I’m not in favor of continuing to over-invest in the OL because just one more pick isn’t going to be the magical fix to the entire OL, but the way Evan Neal has people shell-shocked about switching sides despite playing almost as much RT in college as he did LT is insane to me.
Let’s draft Joe Alt to play WR and RB. Fill 2 positions with 1 pick
This is the answer! He can play guard!
We are not wasting any more draft resources on starting linemen—we have plenty top talent now coach em up! We need a WR1 for starters…
This fanbase really wants the Giants to draft year in year out like the league is 7 on 7🤮
How about draft qb and solidly the franchise for hopefully more than 8+ years
I’ve never seen a guy be so adamantly disagreed with by everyone on their take.
Rather trade for a proven guy instead of risking an Evan Neal 2.0
Trade back a few spots and draft Penix.
Nah We’ve invested enough in OL this season
🙏🙏🙏
While i really like alt, I’ve come to accept that it’s not right to draft a guy that high and then tell him to play a different position
I want a receiver you all are stupid
We just solidified the likenfor 8 years last year
The vast majority of teams get their right tackle in free agency, trades or later rounds.
I agree. Just because booty cheeks Evan Neal couldn’t handle a position change (LT to RT) doesn’t mean Alt or any other lineman cant either. At the same time if Maserati Marv is there at 6 you cant say no
Would be about the dumbest pick imaginable. Imagine wanting to spend YET ANOTHER high pick on the OL even after signing two starters in free agency. Come on. Just silly.
29 comments
Yeah I agree!! Let’s add another LT to the team although we already have an All Pro LT, to solidify the line
Edited: LT not RT
Moving Alt to Right tackle would be a waste, and he’s also never played there, he’s been a Left tackle his whole career, so it could be risky taking him and making him play Right tackle. We also just signed Eluemunor and id also like to Give Neal another year and see what he can do working with Bricillo, a very good O-Line coach.
Nah
Yeah this is a horrible idea, so as a Giants fan I believe it may happen.
My draft hot take is that Fashanu is going to be a better OT than Alt
We need a WR or QB, we have a LT already. We signed 2 linemen in the off season with one of them being a tackle and we got a new oline coach, we can’t keep going for oline this early when we have other needs
Nothing is guaranteed.
Can’t wait for the dogshit draft takes to stop for a few months
Just let Neal develop with a new coach before we throw in the towel. Guy has only played like 20 games
How do I delete this post
Na, we need to show we can develop what we have otherwise it’s Neal 2.0. We can’t draft our way to a better line, time to coach the guys up like the good orgs do.
While I disagree with this post, I also hate that people keep saying that it would be a waste to switch Alt to RT.
Most everyone here should be able to agree that we would love to have the Lion’s OL. Well, the Lion’s built that OL by going and drafting Penei Sewell 7th overall despite having a franchise LT in Taylor Decker — and in spite of Sewell never playing RT in college, is now an all pro RT.
I’m not in favor of continuing to over-invest in the OL because just one more pick isn’t going to be the magical fix to the entire OL, but the way Evan Neal has people shell-shocked about switching sides despite playing almost as much RT in college as he did LT is insane to me.
Let’s draft Joe Alt to play WR and RB. Fill 2 positions with 1 pick
This is the answer! He can play guard!
We are not wasting any more draft resources on starting linemen—we have plenty top talent now coach em up! We need a WR1 for starters…
This fanbase really wants the Giants to draft year in year out like the league is 7 on 7🤮
How about draft qb and solidly the franchise for hopefully more than 8+ years
I’ve never seen a guy be so adamantly disagreed with by everyone on their take.
Rather trade for a proven guy instead of risking an Evan Neal 2.0
Trade back a few spots and draft Penix.
Nah
We’ve invested enough in OL this season
🙏🙏🙏
While i really like alt, I’ve come to accept that it’s not right to draft a guy that high and then tell him to play a different position
I want a receiver you all are stupid
We just solidified the likenfor 8 years last year
The vast majority of teams get their right tackle in free agency, trades or later rounds.
I agree. Just because booty cheeks Evan Neal couldn’t handle a position change (LT to RT) doesn’t mean Alt or any other lineman cant either. At the same time if Maserati Marv is there at 6 you cant say no
Would be about the dumbest pick imaginable. Imagine wanting to spend YET ANOTHER high pick on the OL even after signing two starters in free agency. Come on. Just silly.
Why do you keep calling him Andrews
We said the same thing about Neal