What’s an opinion you have about the Giants that’ll have you like this.
33 comments
I don’t think it’s do or die to get a young QB in the next few years. I think people forget that free agency exists and there’s always a few starting capable QBs that end up being available in the offseason. I wouldn’t pass it up if a good one drops in the draft, but I definitely wouldn’t move up for one.
I’m ok with taking McCarthy, the dominant 3rd and long numbers intrigues me as much as it does coaches/scouts. It’s like, your on a run dominant team your throwing on an obvious throwing down and are successful in those situations over half the time. It translates to the NFL more than padding your stats in blowouts and such.
We aren’t drafting a QB this year and DJ is gonna have a good year with the giants competing for a wildcard spot.
I’m not sold on schoen being here 2 yrs from now hope I’m wrong
A QB will elevate the roster. Even if that QB is good and not great, even a good QB will make the other players on offense perform better because of play execution and adaptability.
The Giants don’t have a QB that elevates the roster.
Barkley is gonna dominate the next couple years making the Giants look like fools
FYI I’m a lifelong Giants fan.
Giants win the Superbowl and Tommy Cutlets is the MVP with 3 turds and 1 running it in
We don’t need a QB for the next 2 or 3 years. It’s time to develop the front of the offense and defense. That’s about 7-12 positions of need we have before we look at skills like QB, HB, TE, WR, CB, F/SS. We need linemen and linebackers.
Is DJ great? No. Sorry. Is he serviceable? Yes, but he’s going to suck without WRs, and he’s going to get nailed and beat down without linemen, causing him to be injured.
Accept that we screwed up our cap by bringing him in, and let’s build the team while we ride out this contract, and in 2 or 3 years we just draft Arch and call it a day with an established team that it took us 3 or 4 drafts to build.
Edit: fat fingered some spelling.
Eagles and Cowboys implode. Giants take the Division.
Giants take McCarthy at 5. He doesn’t see the field all year. Giants compete for WC spot.
Bobby Johnson’s Commanders cripple for life whichever rookie QB they take at 2
DJ’s neck injury is going to end his career early. One more bad hit and he’s going to have to shut it down.
I don’t think we take a QB in the 1st, we will roll the dice with Drew Lock and he will look better than DJ
Drafting Barkley was not the best idea. Loved him while he was on the team, but even when they drafted him I wasn’t super enthused
Giants will trade up for McCarthy if price is right. If they don’t trade up they will take Odunze over Nabers. They will value what he brings on and off the field more.
This fanbase is delusional. I’m gonna get downvoted but the fact that most people in here were happy w us winning meaningless games last season pushing our pick to 6th for the draft is horrible. I’d much rather have a top 3 pick and a chance at a really good QB than winning a meaningless game against the Patriots in Nov. 🤷🏾‍♂️
Nothing the Giants do in the draft matters until the show that they can actually develop talent.
Matt Dodge sucked, but Jesus Christ get over it. He was a bad punter for one year and they won the goddamn Super Bowl the next year.
Let it go, dorks.
Trade back on every single pick to get as many future picks as possible.
The historically bad last ~decade of this franchise has made me lose a little interest in the sport.
Giants need to get one of the top 4 QB’s no matter the cost, and then they need to trade back into the end of the 1st for one of the top remaining WR in this deep class, no matter the cost.
Deal with the lack of future draft picks when it comes and build through FA in the future but get the core now.
We can keep waiting and hoping we marry the right draft pick value to the correct QB, but it’s likely not happening anytime soon. This is the deep QB and deep WR draft to spend the capital.
The Oline is going to be top 15 this year as long as AT doesn’t get injured.
Daniel Jones is pretty good
Wandale Robinson will be a top 15 WR next year
The 2022 season did more damage to this team than the Tommy DeVito wins
i will always love tiki barber – the player at least
We shouldn’t have fired Reese.
I would be fine with taking Penix in the 2nd and having him sit a year. If DJ sucks start Drew Lock, with the option with the option of bring him back next year to compete with Penix. Whomever loses that job in 2025 gets traded, and you draft another 2nd-3rd round guy to sit a year again and repeat.
None the QBs will be any good in the NFL.
Evan Neal will be our swing tackle this year. He’ll lose the RT job to Eluemenor and coaching staff won’t bother with trying him at guard.
I like JJ better than Maye.
– We should’ve moved on from Eli way sooner than we actually did
– Coughlin 100% deserved to be fired after 2015 (Reese too but that’s not really a hot take)
– OBJ’s antics were way overblown and it’s laughable how much emphasis we place on “character concerns” when we’ve literally taken Toney and Baker in previous drafts (not to mention kept Josh Brown employed even after it came out that he was beating his wife). I already see people complaining about character issues with Malik Nabers. If he isn’t an actual criminal and he’s a good football player who gives a shit if he’s cocky or annoying?
– The Tommy Devito shit was annoying as hell and it’s kinda concerning how many people here legitimately thought he was better than Tyrod
We should sign FA and Top NFL Jerker Antonio Brown
33 comments
I don’t think it’s do or die to get a young QB in the next few years. I think people forget that free agency exists and there’s always a few starting capable QBs that end up being available in the offseason. I wouldn’t pass it up if a good one drops in the draft, but I definitely wouldn’t move up for one.
I’m ok with taking McCarthy, the dominant 3rd and long numbers intrigues me as much as it does coaches/scouts. It’s like, your on a run dominant team your throwing on an obvious throwing down and are successful in those situations over half the time. It translates to the NFL more than padding your stats in blowouts and such.
We aren’t drafting a QB this year and DJ is gonna have a good year with the giants competing for a wildcard spot.
I’m not sold on schoen being here 2 yrs from now hope I’m wrong
A QB will elevate the roster. Even if that QB is good and not great, even a good QB will make the other players on offense perform better because of play execution and adaptability.
The Giants don’t have a QB that elevates the roster.
Barkley is gonna dominate the next couple years making the Giants look like fools
FYI I’m a lifelong Giants fan.
Giants win the Superbowl and Tommy Cutlets is the MVP with 3 turds and 1 running it in
We don’t need a QB for the next 2 or 3 years. It’s time to develop the front of the offense and defense. That’s about 7-12 positions of need we have before we look at skills like QB, HB, TE, WR, CB, F/SS. We need linemen and linebackers.
Is DJ great? No. Sorry. Is he serviceable? Yes, but he’s going to suck without WRs, and he’s going to get nailed and beat down without linemen, causing him to be injured.
Accept that we screwed up our cap by bringing him in, and let’s build the team while we ride out this contract, and in 2 or 3 years we just draft Arch and call it a day with an established team that it took us 3 or 4 drafts to build.
Edit: fat fingered some spelling.
Eagles and Cowboys implode. Giants take the Division.
Giants take McCarthy at 5. He doesn’t see the field all year. Giants compete for WC spot.
Bobby Johnson’s Commanders cripple for life whichever rookie QB they take at 2
DJ’s neck injury is going to end his career early. One more bad hit and he’s going to have to shut it down.
I don’t think we take a QB in the 1st, we will roll the dice with Drew Lock and he will look better than DJ
Drafting Barkley was not the best idea. Loved him while he was on the team, but even when they drafted him I wasn’t super enthused
Giants will trade up for McCarthy if price is right. If they don’t trade up they will take Odunze over Nabers. They will value what he brings on and off the field more.
This fanbase is delusional. I’m gonna get downvoted but the fact that most people in here were happy w us winning meaningless games last season pushing our pick to 6th for the draft is horrible. I’d much rather have a top 3 pick and a chance at a really good QB than winning a meaningless game against the Patriots in Nov. 🤷🏾‍♂️
Nothing the Giants do in the draft matters until the show that they can actually develop talent.
Matt Dodge sucked, but Jesus Christ get over it. He was a bad punter for one year and they won the goddamn Super Bowl the next year.
Let it go, dorks.
Trade back on every single pick to get as many future picks as possible.
The historically bad last ~decade of this franchise has made me lose a little interest in the sport.
Giants need to get one of the top 4 QB’s no matter the cost, and then they need to trade back into the end of the 1st for one of the top remaining WR in this deep class, no matter the cost.
Deal with the lack of future draft picks when it comes and build through FA in the future but get the core now.
We can keep waiting and hoping we marry the right draft pick value to the correct QB, but it’s likely not happening anytime soon. This is the deep QB and deep WR draft to spend the capital.
The Oline is going to be top 15 this year as long as AT doesn’t get injured.
Daniel Jones is pretty good
Wandale Robinson will be a top 15 WR next year
The 2022 season did more damage to this team than the Tommy DeVito wins
i will always love tiki barber – the player at least
We shouldn’t have fired Reese.
I would be fine with taking Penix in the 2nd and having him sit a year. If DJ sucks start Drew Lock, with the option with the option of bring him back next year to compete with Penix. Whomever loses that job in 2025 gets traded, and you draft another 2nd-3rd round guy to sit a year again and repeat.
None the QBs will be any good in the NFL.
Evan Neal will be our swing tackle this year. He’ll lose the RT job to Eluemenor and coaching staff won’t bother with trying him at guard.
I like JJ better than Maye.
– We should’ve moved on from Eli way sooner than we actually did
– Coughlin 100% deserved to be fired after 2015 (Reese too but that’s not really a hot take)
– OBJ’s antics were way overblown and it’s laughable how much emphasis we place on “character concerns” when we’ve literally taken Toney and Baker in previous drafts (not to mention kept Josh Brown employed even after it came out that he was beating his wife). I already see people complaining about character issues with Malik Nabers. If he isn’t an actual criminal and he’s a good football player who gives a shit if he’s cocky or annoying?
– The Tommy Devito shit was annoying as hell and it’s kinda concerning how many people here legitimately thought he was better than Tyrod
We should sign FA and Top NFL Jerker Antonio Brown