McGary? Really up and down sometimes.
Divided for sure because of both on and off the field stuff.
Kaleb McGary for sure.
I’d say Calvin Ridley. Was good to above average, no one was really a frantic fan but no one really disliked him until he left
Kroy Bierman
I’m team Ridley on this one.
Currently, has to be Kyle Pitts. He’s average about 50 catches for 600+ yards and 2 TDs per season, which is dead ass average. Fans hate him b/c his production doesn’t match his draft position. Fans like him b/c he is supposed to be a unicorn and for about 5 plays a game, he is.
Maybe the ratio of fan division pushes him to average/hated but it’s hard to tell on the enterwebz.
Harry Douglas
Julio. Some ppl are very pissed at how he left. And I think he was a ‘good’ player.
Kaleb Mcgary
I feel like this is where Mike Vick goes. Obviously hugely divded sentiment among fans, and despite his incredible rushing game was decidedly mid as an all-around QB.
Dee Alford is nearly the most league average cornerback you can find according to PFF. Feels like opinions are split on him around here?
Devonta Freeman
Vick most fans love him but ok
Maybe Kazee?
still disagree that Vick was a good player
TJ Duckett
patrick kerney or keith brookings
actually im gonna go desmond trufant on this one
Dunta Robinson
Robert Alford: He’d make huge plays, get burned, or get penalized. Fans loved him when he played well, hated him when he’d get that inevitable 3rd down holding call
20 comments
McGary? Really up and down sometimes.
Divided for sure because of both on and off the field stuff.
Kaleb McGary for sure.
I’d say Calvin Ridley. Was good to above average, no one was really a frantic fan but no one really disliked him until he left
Kroy Bierman
I’m team Ridley on this one.
Currently, has to be Kyle Pitts. He’s average about 50 catches for 600+ yards and 2 TDs per season, which is dead ass average. Fans hate him b/c his production doesn’t match his draft position. Fans like him b/c he is supposed to be a unicorn and for about 5 plays a game, he is.
Maybe the ratio of fan division pushes him to average/hated but it’s hard to tell on the enterwebz.
Harry Douglas
Julio. Some ppl are very pissed at how he left. And I think he was a ‘good’ player.
Kaleb Mcgary
I feel like this is where Mike Vick goes. Obviously hugely divded sentiment among fans, and despite his incredible rushing game was decidedly mid as an all-around QB.
Dee Alford is nearly the most league average cornerback you can find according to PFF. Feels like opinions are split on him around here?
Devonta Freeman
Vick most fans love him but ok
Maybe Kazee?
still disagree that Vick was a good player
TJ Duckett
patrick kerney or keith brookings
actually im gonna go desmond trufant on this one
Dunta Robinson
Robert Alford: He’d make huge plays, get burned, or get penalized. Fans loved him when he played well, hated him when he’d get that inevitable 3rd down holding call