Aaron Rodgers won good player, fans are divided! Today’s is average player, fans are divided.
January 23, 2025
Aaron Rodgers won good player, fans are divided! Today’s is average player, fans are divided.
36 comments
AJ Hawk? Morgan Burnett?
Eddy Lacy maybe?
Rashan Gary
aj hawk when he was playing, over rated 1st round pick.
Im gonna get flamed for it but Rashan Gary. I’ve been against him being drafted since day 1 and he’s about mid as they come. Took 2+ years to actually show up then plagued with injuries, mid performance while getting a lot of money. I know a lot of people like him so that’s why I say he belongs there.
AJ Hawk for sure
Atari Bigby?
Can you add names to these? I don’t know all the players by their face.
Terell Buckley.
Was an ok overall player with a 12 year career in the league. Just happened to lose to receivers over 6 feet tall at bad times. People of the time loved him and hated him, often switching between the two at kneejerk speeds.
Ha Ha Clinton Dix
Mike McKenzie
Jermichael Finley
Never made a probowl but certainly had the talent to be that kind of player. Good enough to stay on the field but impossible to call great.
Painfully inconsistent and a very unfortunate injury.
AJ or Lacy
Going to have to dodge tomatoes on this one, which I deserve since this is somewhat tongue in cheek but still a good answer IMO:
Jordan Love
Jarrett Bush.
Mark Chmura is the answer here. Was never bad, was never elite. Isn’t a very good person based on some past actions but is still remembered fondly by some due to his time during the 90s super bowl runs.
Preston Smith
HaHa Clinton-Dix
Gotta be AJ Hawk
I can see how AJ would fit the average player aspect given he didn’t quite meet the expectation of a 1st rounder especially top 5.
But I am confused why he would be nominated today as he would also need to fit the narrative that a large portion (around half if were considering this divided) of fans actually did not like him as a player? Good dude, good teammate, never a distraction, consistent for many years.
In my eyes, he fits average player loved by fans much more than this. Being underwhelmed with his turnout due to draft position doesn’t quite equate to being hated by half our fandom.
Gonna get ahead of things and nominate the final row:
Darren Sharper
Martellus Bennett
Brandon Bostick
Don Majkowski
Jarrett Bush — Above average special teams player, below average defender. Some people liked him, some people hated him. I always thought he was perfectly average and ok as a depth piece or in nickel situations.
What fans are divided for Aaron Rodgers. The “i still own you” lives rent free in my head. 😂
AJ Dillon
Jermichael Finley for sure. Some thought he was great, some thought he was a bum. His drops kept him out of the good category for me
AJ hawk, maybe Preston smith, Nick Perry, HA HA I think fits here
Greg jennings
Jermichael Finley. Had all the ability, could never put it together, though
Quay Walker. Makes a lot of bone headed plays, but some might still feel there’s potential there.
Should include coaches and go with Dom Capers. He had some great years and some terrible years, and fans have opinions on him ranging from decent coach whose schemes got old and stale all the way to literal football terrorist.
Rashan Gary lmao
Eddie Lacy
Who is Divided on Rodgers? Sorry thats mental illness. He was mahomes before mahomes, he is the reason why 50% of us are here
36 comments
AJ Hawk? Morgan Burnett?
Eddy Lacy maybe?
Rashan Gary
aj hawk when he was playing, over rated 1st round pick.
Im gonna get flamed for it but Rashan Gary. I’ve been against him being drafted since day 1 and he’s about mid as they come. Took 2+ years to actually show up then plagued with injuries, mid performance while getting a lot of money. I know a lot of people like him so that’s why I say he belongs there.
AJ Hawk for sure
Atari Bigby?
Can you add names to these? I don’t know all the players by their face.
Terell Buckley.
Was an ok overall player with a 12 year career in the league. Just happened to lose to receivers over 6 feet tall at bad times. People of the time loved him and hated him, often switching between the two at kneejerk speeds.
Ha Ha Clinton Dix
Mike McKenzie
Jermichael Finley
Never made a probowl but certainly had the talent to be that kind of player. Good enough to stay on the field but impossible to call great.
Painfully inconsistent and a very unfortunate injury.
AJ or Lacy
Going to have to dodge tomatoes on this one, which I deserve since this is somewhat tongue in cheek but still a good answer IMO:
Jordan Love
Jarrett Bush.
Mark Chmura is the answer here. Was never bad, was never elite. Isn’t a very good person based on some past actions but is still remembered fondly by some due to his time during the 90s super bowl runs.
Preston Smith
HaHa Clinton-Dix
Gotta be AJ Hawk
I can see how AJ would fit the average player aspect given he didn’t quite meet the expectation of a 1st rounder especially top 5.
But I am confused why he would be nominated today as he would also need to fit the narrative that a large portion (around half if were considering this divided) of fans actually did not like him as a player? Good dude, good teammate, never a distraction, consistent for many years.
In my eyes, he fits average player loved by fans much more than this. Being underwhelmed with his turnout due to draft position doesn’t quite equate to being hated by half our fandom.
Gonna get ahead of things and nominate the final row:
Darren Sharper
Martellus Bennett
Brandon Bostick
Don Majkowski
Jarrett Bush — Above average special teams player, below average defender. Some people liked him, some people hated him. I always thought he was perfectly average and ok as a depth piece or in nickel situations.
What fans are divided for Aaron Rodgers. The “i still own you” lives rent free in my head. 😂
AJ Dillon
Jermichael Finley for sure. Some thought he was great, some thought he was a bum. His drops kept him out of the good category for me
AJ hawk, maybe Preston smith, Nick Perry, HA HA I think fits here
Greg jennings
Jermichael Finley. Had all the ability, could never put it together, though
Quay Walker. Makes a lot of bone headed plays, but some might still feel there’s potential there.
Should include coaches and go with Dom Capers. He had some great years and some terrible years, and fans have opinions on him ranging from decent coach whose schemes got old and stale all the way to literal football terrorist.
Rashan Gary lmao
Eddie Lacy
Who is Divided on Rodgers? Sorry thats mental illness. He was mahomes before mahomes, he is the reason why 50% of us are here
AJ Hawk, Eddy Lacy, Romeo Doubs (basically our whole receiving corps)
Rashan Gary.