DeWayne Wise finishes out the first row. Now, who’s a good player that fans are divided on?

19 comments

1. Chris Sale

2. TimAnderson

3. AJ Pierzynski

4. Chris Sale has got to be the answer here. I’m saving AJ for the center square.

5. Magglio Ordóñez

6. This one’s easy, definitely Sale

7. Adam Dunn. Would he count? Cuz he was good other places but mostly ass for us. I know some people liked him, but I couldn’t stand him.

8. Shoeless Joe.

   I suspect most people are divided within themselves. Not great to sabatoge your team, but also a product of his circumstances so it’s kind of understandable. Also we need to not-recent folks in here.

9. Kevin Youkilis?

10. Yoan Moncada is the easy answer for me 

    He was objectively a “good” player (not great) but even in his better years fans were still divided on him. 

11. AJ for me. I love him but i know people who dont

12. Albert Belle

13. For some reason Juan Pierre comes to mind. Please correct me if I’m wrong though, I was quite young during his time with the Sox haha

14. Carlos Quentin

15. John Danks

16. Adam Eaton comes to mind after his last run with us.

17. Adam Eaton maybe? His first stint with us he was good.

18. Who doesn’t love AJ Pierzynski?? This is the most Chris Sale category that exists

19. Adam Eaton

    If “fans” are divided on Chris Sale they’re just stupid.