Here are the names for everybody left to right:

Loved by fans: Donald Driver, James Jones, Jeff Janis.

Fans are divided: Aaron Rodgers, Jermichael Finley, Marquez Valdes-Scantling.

Hated by fans: Darren Sharper (couldn’t find his Packers picture)

45 comments

  20. Kevin King

    When available he was usually average, but got burned in a few key spots that earned him a terrible reputation

  26. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix. I place more blame on him than Bostick for the 2014 NFCC game. He was standing there like a moron on the 2 point conversion, right next to the Seahawks receiver and he did absolutely nothing. I could’ve knocked that ball down. He watched a pass go right by him against the Steelers the next year (iirc, might not be the right year). Just dumb as hell at some key times, maybe not even an average player, but I hate him.

  28. Blake Martinez. The fans practically ran the guy out of town. Definitely average or slightly below not bad.

  30. Tony Mandarich? Guy was a revolving door.

    Edit: Oops, this is for average player. I’d say Atari Bigby. Dude got burned as much he made great plays.

  32. Zadarius Smith. Good at times, I think a little unstable, not a good lockeroom presence, “injured” at times and unavailable.

  38. Bears fan coming in peace. Ya’ll are divided on Rodgers? Is it solely because of his off-the-field antics?

  42. In 1986, Charles Martin [body slammed](https://youtu.be/Ev3prLKRLzs?si=vsqA4Oqb2AI-wA-O) Jim McMahon directly onto a previously injured shoulder, well after he had thrown the ball. The hit essentially ended his career.

    Martin had displayed a hand towel during pre-game warmups with the numbers of McMahon, Walter Payton, and several other Bears players. The act earned Martin the first multi-game suspension in modern NFL history for an on-field incident, and the hatred of the entire league.

    He was suspended for two more games that same year for an incident at a Green Bay bar, and was arrested the following year for disorderly conduct (he egged a players car lol). Packers finally cut bait, but the Oilers picked him up that same year where he finished the season. Falcons picked him up that following year, which was his last.

    He was drafted as a DE but he moved to DT after his first year. He showed flashes of being an above average player, but you won’t find many strong arguments he was either good or objectively bad.

  43. Bad Player/Hated by fans has to be Martellus Bennett. Has to be. MFer just quit on us because Aaron went down with an injury then faked an injury of his own during the bye week, was cut and then playing for the Patriots again the next week. F that guy so hard.

  44. Martellus Bennett. Good overall career, was very average with us, and shit talked his way off the team. Fuck that guy

Leave a Reply