No surprise with this one. Which Padres was OK but had a good fan reputation? Day 2

50 comments
  1. Definitely Will, but I want to throw an early one for day 3: Chris Denorfia! In those dark days he was always hustling out there.

  2. It has to be Khalil Greene. Flashy defense but back of his baseball card is totally average. Still, we’ll never forget him.

  3. Wil Myers fact 6538: he was beloved by fans, but only an OK player (with some good stretches back in the day)

  4. I know it’s way back now, but this sub was head over heels for Franmil Reyes for the vibes he brought. Dude even got SD tattooed.

    Wil is a good pick and has the time on the team, but La Mole deserves an honorable mention

  5. Tony Gwynn, Wil Myers, Chris Denorfia
    Adrian Gonzalez, Justin Upton, Chase Headly
    Eric Hosmer, Matt Kemp, Austin Hedges

    Final answer.

  6. Wil Myers was a little better than average. But seems like the runaway answer here.

    I’d say Chris Denorfia. Yangervis Solarte also comes to mind.

  7. This is definitely Kim IMO. Solid player. But you’d think he was a superstar by the fan support.

Leave a Reply