Braun was our good player that we have mixed feelings for. Day 5. Who’s an average player that fans have mixed feelings about?

42 comments

1. Travis Shaw

2. Craig Counsell

3. Kyle Lohse feels kind of appropriate for this. Zach Davies honorable mention.

4. I’ll throw JJ Hardy out there for the mixed/average combo (if ya know, ya know 😉).

5. Might be controversial but Junior Guerra

6. Trent Grisham

7. Orlando Arcia

8. Ron Belliard

9. Eric Gagne

10. Suppan?

11. Carlos Gomez

12. In what universe does anybody have mixed feelings about Counsell?

    Also he was closer to bad player than average.

    He’ll be on this grid but this is completely the wrong square

13. Jeff Suppan

14. Ricky Weeks, sometimes good, sometimes bad. Pretty decent all things considered, but alot of people probably expected more given his potential

15. Nyjer Morgan

16. jeremy jeffress

17. Bill Bruton

18. Corey Hart

19. Suppan, Lohse, Garza. All basically identical and interchangeable.

20. Keon Broxton

21. T plush

22. Jerry Augestine

23. Matt Garza

24. El Caballo

25. I say Orlando Arcia

26. Jamey Wright. Felt like he had great stuff but was wildly inconsistent. Had a lengthy career though.

    Yovani Gallardo as well. Had some good years but felt like it could’ve been better. Think he liked to party and it caught up with him/never quite reached his peak.

27. Rickie Weeks

28. Weeks

29. Jeff Suppan

30. Yovani Gallardo

31. Craig Counsell!

32. Greg (Council) or Tony Plush

33. JJ Hardy….stole all the women and left few for the rest of us.

34. Ricky Bones. The true definition of an average player, but mixed feelings as he was the “centerpiece” of the Sheffield trade.

35. Jeff Suppan

36. Matt Garza

37. T-Plush

38. Craig Counsell

39. Freddy Peralta. Great when he’s on but never really takes that step forward to being consistently more than a solid #3 or #4

40. No love for “hammerin’” Hank Aaron?

41. Suter

42. Jeromy Burnitz