JHay is the average player we all love. Now who’s a player, current or former, that we all love but he sucks

44 comments

1. Francisco Cervelli

2. John wehner

3. Pedro Alvarez

4. Fort McKenry!

5. John Nogowski

6. How about Drew Maggi? That was a fun story.

7. Is Drew Maggi a fair answer?

8. Mario Mendoza, forever a part of baseball lore.

9. Lunchbox – Travis Snider

10. Tony Sanchez

11. Rowdy Tellez

12. Adam Hyzdu

13. Gift Ngoepe

14. Drew Maggi has to be the answer here.

15. Gregory Polanco

16. Rambo Diaz

17. Clint Barmes

18. Chad Kuhl

19. Kevin Polcovich. He would’ve never sniffed the majors if Kevin Elster didn’t get hurt. But he was a fan favorite on the 1997 team especially after he hit a home run off of Curt Schilling.

20. John Jaso

21. It’s gotta be Drew Maggi. The determination and dedication he showed was admirable but he just didn’t have it

22. Jack Wilson

23. Kevin young

24. Steven brault

25. Rod Barajas

26. Andy LaRoche or Zach Duke.

27. Finishing that left column is gonna be pretty tough

28. Ryan Doumit.

29. Brad Eldred

30. Mike Diaz

31. Henry Davis?

32. Should just put a pirate logo here. Too many options

33. ROWDY TELLEZ

34. This could be the longest thread in this sub… I’ll submit Rob Mackowiak.

35. Jose Lind

36. Tony Womack

    Was an all star at -1 WAR

37. Rafael Belliard

38. The correct answer is Sean Rodriguez

39. Mario Mendoza

40. We came to love Daniel Vogelbach in his 75 games, didn’t we?

41. Jaff Decker

42. Cervelli

43. Fat Jimmy Anderson

44. John Wehner. 

    He had a negative WAR with the Pirates, stuck around for years, had a nickname and was generally loved by the fan base. So he has the negative impact on the field and the longevity and I mean I don’t know anyone who doesn’t like him.