You Ask We Answer: Post-Draft Buffalo Bills Questions

Your home for coverage of the Buffalo Bills.

Mike Catalana and Jenna Cottrell answer your questions on the Bills now after the 2025 Draft, what to make of special teams and who looks to be on the roster bubble.

For links to all our coverage and the Buffalo Plus Store: https://www.flowcode.com/page/buffaloplus

Don’t forget, you can also catch all our episodes on your
favorite podcast platforms like Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and
more: https://www.flowcode.com/page/buffaloplus

For more behind-the-scenes content and on the field coverage on game day from Orchard Park, follow us at:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/buffaloplusdotcom
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/buffaloplus_/?hl=en
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@buffaloplus_
X (Twitter): https://twitter.com/BuffaloPlus

Mike’s X: https://twitter.com/MikeCatalana
Dan’s X: https://twitter.com/danfetes
Dan’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/danfetes/
Jenna’s X: https://twitter.com/JennaCottrell
Jenna’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jennacottrell/?hl=en

Buffalo Plus MERCH: BuffaloPlusStore.com

Website: https://13wham.com/buffalo-plus

Please like, comment and subscribe!

46 comments
  1. Beane will not be on the hot seat for making the playoffs year after year but not winning a championship. BUT, the seat could get hot if he alienates the media and creates a distraction or weakens the team’s reputation. Monday was the mistake. Beane needs to own that and reconcile before the media becomes the story.

  2. Gabe has no value if he’s not starting, doesn’t play ST. Mack Hollins will dress every game as he’s on all ST units. If they bring back Gabe, I don’t see him getting a jersey during games. He’d be inactive.

  3. Amari Cooper would still be better than Gabe Davis. Neither play ST but at least Amari may have more to offer. He’d was very good at getting open until last year.

  4. Jeremy didn’t just criticize Beane, he ripped apart his entire approach to this years draft. Go watch the 2 hours of nonsense before Beane came on. He even said that he didn’t think Beane was objectively selecting players based on the prepared draft board. Quite an attack on his integrity and process.

    If members of the media pins their ears back and project a narrative that Beane is (in Jeremy’s words) in the way of Josh Allen succeeding and not doing his job then Beane has every right to defend himself. If you’re going to criticize his decisions it needs to be fair and balanced. Intimating that Beane doesn’t understand the value of certain positions just because he didn’t draft who YOU wanted is unfair.

    Don’t end up on the wrong side of this. I get Jeremy is a fellow member of the media, but he is also immature and thinks his words and attacks should have no consequence. He is the only one in the media spending every bit of his airtime criticizing one of the most respected GMs in the league who has a phenomenal track record of turning this franchise around. Don’t forget that he is the sole reason we have Josh Allen. He made several moves to gain position in the draft and picked a guy who will be in the HOF. Most of the folks at WGR didn’t even think Allen was good.

    Thankful we have Beane as a GM. He is better at his job than Jeremy White is at his, and it’s not even close

  5. Do you think Brandon Beane feels like he is in a bind now with his comments? Could he sign a receiver? I hope he is not reluctant to sign one just because people might rub it in his face

  6. I honestly don't want Gabe back, even if Beane got a good deal on him. He's led the league in dropped passes and hasn't shown that he's improved. He would pick the opposite option for the route from where Josh was throwing. Gabe was one of the reasons drives would stall, Josh's completion numbers were always low, and his interception numbers were high.

  7. Let’s test your football IQ Jenna.

    What’s more important to the team… taking a DE in the 3rd that will contribute significant snaps this season and slot in there as a starter next season… or taking a 5th WR for an offense that runs primarily 2 & 3 WR sets? A WR whose primary role will be special teams and occasional sub packages?

    What’s more important, taking a nose tackle in the fourth to replace the aging and declining Daquan Jones… that will contribute significant snaps this season and slot in as the starter next season… or taking a 5th WR for an offense that runs primarily 2 & 3 WR sets? A WR whose primary role will be special teams and occasional sub packages?

    What’s more important to the roster, taking a CB in the 5th that’s a perfect scheme fit at a position that has been plagued with injuries the past three years and that we consistently go into the playoffs without enough of or….

    taking a 5th WR for an offense that runs primarily 2 & 3 WR sets? A WR whose primary role will be special teams and occasional sub packages?

  8. I thought when they drafted Javon Solomon they would move him to linebacker because of his size. Last season, I thought the Bills said there were a lot of teams interested in Epenesa. When he becomes a free agent, he will be offered a lot of money by other teams. The Bills can't afford him. So he is gone. Maybe they will trade him if they can before the season ends instead of getting compensation picks. Tyrell Shavers had flashes at the end of last season. I wonder if he will break through this year. Last year, if the Bills would have held their opponents to 10 points each game they would have gone undefeated. Brandon Beane was right. They didn't need to draft a wide receiver. When you need to score 48 and 44 points to win a game there is nothing wrong with your offense. James Cook will be interesting. His brother made the same mistake asking for too much money. I wonder if the Bills can afford him. I think other teams would like to have him but will he lose his mojo if he plays somewhere else? I think his brother did. Or it could have been that teams soured on him because of his attitude. I don't think running backs are as valued as they used to be. Except for maybe Saquon Barkley.
    I think the Bills would love to keep James Cook but maybe they can't afford him.

  9. Which defensive pick do you replace with a wr. They scored over 30/game so I guess they can score 40 points a game and get beat 45 to 40.
    I get a laugh when some of these channels (not this one) grade the current draft. That's like your teacher grading your test before you take it!

  10. I decided to unsubscribe, at least for a while. BP was totally ridiculous Monday in supporting J. White and his ridiculous wide receiver narrative.

  11. There’s a good reason some people have a communication degrees on an AM radio station throwing rocks and crying all year, year after year and some run multibillion $ NFL franchises 🤷🏼‍♂️. Jeremy White is a douche and a clown 🤡

  12. News flash Jenna, no NFL team give AF what YOU think they should have done. There’s a reason you’re yapping on YT and BB is running a multibillion $ NFL team 🤡

  13. I love the Landen Jackson pick the most. I really think he may end up being the best player of this Bills draft. I wouldn't be shocked if he ends up being a pro bowl player. When I first seen him and his highlights I had visions of Bryce Paup.

  14. Fact is we need a receiver, none of our receivers scare nobody in the league, we should keep cooper and sign Elijah Moore or I seen Pickens is going to be available, we need someone who can stretch the field….Coleman sucks he was last in the league in separation so he’s irrelevant on the roster, Shakir our reliable receiver we have, we can’t go into every season with mediocre receivers…. Beane is wasting Allen’s best years by not getting him no help

  15. Why are we bringing back players we got rid of? White is a shell of himself, Dane Jackson was never good, Gabe Davis is avg at best, in 6-7 years when Allen retires and we have no championship it will be on Beane , any other GM had Allen he would make sure Allen had reliable weapons, not switch receivers year after year that are avg players

  16. Personally I belive KC will implode this season, expectations of a team constantly being on top and wining superbowls just not realistic

  17. I have a car. It has all 4 wheels but no lights and oil. the wheels arent the best ones, but they do a decent job

    Buffalo negative: Why don't you get another wheel though? Don't invest all your money on the things you need, spend some on one more wheel.

Leave a Reply