Would You Give Kyle Schwarber a Five-Year Deal to Keep Him in Philadelphia? #phillies #ringthebell
I’d be shocked if Kyle Schwarber was not back in a Philly’s uniform only because there is no chance in hell that they’re going to allow him to leave. They won’t be outbid. I can’t imagine a world where John Middleton says, “No, I’m not going to go fifth year. Sorry, I was willing to go four years with you, Kyle. I’m not going a fifth year. I’m going to go ahead and let you go to the Red Sox or the Yankees or the Mets or whoever.” So, I do not believe Kyle Schwarber is going to be gone. I guess the question is, should they consider not bringing him back? I don’t know. Ray Dunn, do you think he’s back? I think he’s back, but would you give him the fifth year? Yes. You specifically would give him the fifth year. If it meant losing him or giving him the fifth year, why do I care? This team’s cooked once once once the once they’re done this run and Trey Turner isn’t isn’t good anymore, which is coming. Once Bryce Harper isn’t as good anymore, which coming, right? Like you have JT. They’re bring they’re gonna bring JT back, too. It’s a matter does he get three years or he get two years. They’re bringing all these old guys back, dude. He’s coming back. He’s giving the fifth year. And yeah, I’m giving him the fifth year. Yeah.
📸: Emilee Chinn and Michael Reaves/Getty Images
20 comments
Signing Schwarber would be a disaster. You will have 100+ million of dead money in 2 years. Turner, Schwarber, Nola, JT, etc . Let him walk and get a #1 pitcher.
No.
I'd make him the highest paid for 2026 by offering him a one-year deal that would pay him the most for the 2026 season. I would not offer a multi-year contract.
Let him go, choke champion
Let him go. Sign Hoskins and go after Kyle Tucker.
Definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results.
I would not give him a five year contract and I’m a fan of Kyle Schwarber. Guys are getting older through no fault of their own; Nola for example, over paid.
TURNER HARPER SWABER JT GET RID OF REST AND EVERY RELIEF PITCHER GOES
ALVERADO NOPE
If they go 5, think of how bad the Phillies will be in that fifth year. Ood Schwarber, old Harper, old Turner.
Man, the 2030 Phillies are gonna be a disaster.
Let him walk, make Harper DH, keep Ranger and JT. So simple. And you can get Alonso at 1st.
There are other players out there. He won't get better.
SEND SCHWARBER PACKING
5 YEARS ARE THEY FUCKING CRAZY
People who don’t want him back aren’t Phillies fans. Schwarber is the leader not Harper. Harper is a bum. Schwarbs deserves anything he asks for
Yes, then unload the garbage
After they get their big contract they start slowing down
Love swhwarber but u can get an everyday player 4 that money. Harper dh bye bye stott casty marsh n Kepler n if u can get something 4 bohm. Also Kevin long see ya
5 year deal. No way. I love schwarber bombs we have so many holes to fill
Ryan Howard 2.0?
I would if it means Harper goes and we sign Tucker. I’d love to get out of the Harper contract and that would enable you to change up the core and get younger