JJ McCarthy Was One Of The Most Disappointing Players In 2025

18 comments

1. Disappointing for you maybe , you’re a Vikings fan. We knew he wasn’t that good or would take time. Injuries killed his development

2. Vikings fans are disappointed cause they had way too much faith in McCarthy. He was seen as a project coming out of college.

   Expecting him to be a Williams, Daniels, or Maye coming off a season ending injury was really expecting too much

3. Dude is getting yeeted in the pocket lol

4. Should’ve gotten Rodgers to fulfill the Brett Farve prophecy

5. I'd like to know who was more disappointing. I mean, isn't this the guy you moved on from Darnold for?

6. Playoffs??

7. And they had the 31st offensive line this year not much you could do. People make the excuse of offensive line for burrow but yet he has a better o line than the Vikings, JJ was fine he finished 6-4 in his ten starts, Drake Maye went 1-9, Bo nix 6-4, Jayden Daniels 5-5, Caleb 4-6, Penix 4-6. People say he’s the worst one but yet has the most wins in their first ten starts other than being tied with nix

8. I still believe in JJ McCarthy

9. 9

10. Darnold gets you 14-3 oh yeah lets get rid of that guy😂

11. Carson wentz 2.0

12. I think it is crazy how strongly we overvalue bad playoff performances – like Darnold – and then we are surprised the QB who won 14 games, is actually not bad

13. No doubt should've kept Darnold for another yr.or two but JJ will get better…the talent is there…

14. Show some respect on his name, his name isn’t JJ, it’s Nine

15. JJ is going to be just fine if he can stay healthy.

16. Been saying it since midway through 2022 they need to Fire Kwesi.

17. If you can’t get Justin Jefferson the ball consistently, you’re a terrible quarterback.

18. Wait so they went 14-3 with Sam Donald get rid of him he goes to the Seahawks and they’re 14-3 as well ,all right Sam Donald’s obviously the solution and not the problem