Hey all. Wanted to share another episode from my afc west (minus the chiefs) podcast. This week we debated an all Bronco/Charger/Raider all pro team. We don’t take ourselves too seriously as actual analysts so we aren’t touching the combine/draft at all yet. Just three guys shooting the shit and talking ball. My buddy and I started the conversation by debating which QB should be the representative on the all pro team. Obviously Geno was out so it was a two man race, Nix V Herbert. Wanted to see what you guys thought about the debate. I ended up convincing our other host so Nix ended up being the guy. I personally think Herbert is wildly overrated and as talented as he may be, will never win a Super Bowl or even give a serious push. I know this forum is all over the place when it comes to Nix, so I was curious how everyone stacks his season against Herbert’s. Would appreciate any feedback. Both on the argument or the podcast itself. Thanks!
Cheers!
Alex
2 comments
Herbert is a better QB (I’m a Bronco Fan). What he did last year with no offensive line was unbelievable. He melted in thr playoff game, but that happens. There was a whole thing about how Manning wasnt clutch until he was.
Nix is good, and his best traits aren’t flashy. Not saying that Nix is done improving and Bronco fans could hope that someday he’s as good as Hebert, but its clear right now.
You can post stats or throwing motion or whatever you want. My eye test tells me Nix has surpassed Herbert just by what he’s done and how far he’s gotten in two seasons.